IMDb 5.9 2018 HD

A Modest Defeat

A Modest Defeat

2018
Adventure Drama
9 min NR USA
7 / 10
5.9 IMDB

It's civil war in suburbia between two young siblings. Big brother Tommy never plays fair, but eight-year-old Tiny has an elaborate plan up her sleeve and a faultless…

Personnel // Cast & Crew

Director David Barr

How Viewers Describe This Film

Common themes and sentiments

clever determined sibling rivalry strategic domestic conflict unfair ingenious child protagonist focused relatable intense personal victory

Reviews

I
Isabelle Moreau
Apr 11, 2026
3.5 / 5
3.5

'A Modest Defeat' offers a micro-level examination of conflict, focusing on the domestic skirmishes between siblings Tommy and Tiny. The plot, centred on Tiny’s elaborate scheme to counter her brother’s unfair tactics, promises a narrative rich in ingenuity…

D
David Sterling
Apr 11, 2026
4.5 / 5
4.5

The seemingly placid streets of suburbia conceal a fierce 'civil war' in 'A Modest Defeat,' waged between siblings Tommy and Tiny. This is not a grand spectacle, but an intimate, keenly observed drama where fairness is a precious…

C
Clara Bellweather
Apr 11, 2026
3.0 / 5
3.0

'A Modest Defeat' presents a concentrated study of sibling dynamics, transforming a typical household into a theatre of war. The central premise, pitting the unfair Tommy against the strategic Tiny, offers a unique lens on childhood power struggles.…

A
Arthur Finch
Apr 11, 2026
4.0 / 5
4.0

Suburbia's veneer is peeled back in 'A Modest Defeat,' revealing a surprisingly potent sibling rivalry. Tommy, the older brother, embodies a certain disregard for fair play, setting the stage for his younger sister, Tiny, to enact a masterstroke…

E
Eleanor Vance
Apr 11, 2026
3.5 / 5
3.5

In 'A Modest Defeat,' the suburban landscape becomes an unlikely battleground for sibling warfare. The film pits the roguish Tommy against his eight-year-old sister, Tiny, who, despite her size, harbours a formidable intellect and an unyielding quest for…

FAQs

Audiences can anticipate a viewing experience that is likely to be engaging and perhaps surprisingly intricate, given the plot's focus on a young protagonist's well-orchestrated plan. The description suggests a narrative driven by character dynamics and strategic manoeuvring rather than large-scale action. The 'civil war in suburbia' framing implies a tone that could range from lighthearted to intensely focused, offering a compelling, character-driven story about asserting one's will and seeking fairness.